This op-ed appeared in Policy Options on February 14, 2017.
By Tanya van Biesen, executive director, Catalyst Canada and speaker at Universities Canada’s Converge 2017.
The best way to ensure the advancement of women to boards and executive positions is through the use of targets.
The conversation about women on boards in Canada has shifted in an encouraging direction over the past two years – it’s no longer a dialogue focused on why we need more women at the table, but rather on how we can get more of them there faster. That’s thanks in part to new securities law rule amendments to encourage greater representation of women on boards and in executive officer positions.
But even though we’re beginning to see meaningful action on the issue, the reality is we’re still a long way from reaching the ultimate goal: gender parity in boardrooms and at all levels of corporations. Organizations cannot compete effectively in a global economy when they leverage the talents of only half of their workforces. They can and should be doing more to build inclusive workplaces that recognize, develop and advance women and men.
In September 2015, some Canadian securities administrators released a progress review of the new disclosure amendments for TSX-listed companies. It revealed that scant few have adopted targets for the appointment of women to boards or executive officer positions. Their top reason for not doing so? A belief that candidates should be selected based on merit.
Yet research shows that advancement based solely on merit is a concept that rarely — if ever — occurs in actual workplaces, and are burdened by systemic inequities.
For far too long, many Canadian companies have relied on tokenism, with one or two women directors seen as success. We can do much better than that. It’s time to advance more of the record number of highly educated, experienced, and board-ready women in Canada to boards and executive positions.
The most efficient way to do this is through the establishment of targets — the very targets that too many Canadian companies have yet to adopt. The rationale is simple: it’s impossible to measure progress without first having something to measure it against. Organizations that understand this thinking have already set targets for women directors, and indeed, many are demonstrating strong leadership by committing to increasing those targets over time.
It’s in their best interests, after all. Companies need to have more representative corporate governance to better reflect their stakeholders. Indeed, businesses large and small, private and public, have much to gain from boosting the number of women directors and women in leadership. Increasing the number of women in powerful positions has the potential to transform not just our workplaces, but society at large.
Yet research shows that women face many challenges in their careers that men do not, making it harder for them to break through to critical positions. These challenges include gender stereotyping, lower initial job placement, lower pay, slower advancement even when using the same career strategies as men, less access to larger, more visible, mission-critical and international projects and less access to highly placed sponsors who can accelerate career growth that leads to opportunities. Simply put, women have to work harder to get noticed and get access.
We have a responsibility to change that.
To accelerate the pace of change, much bolder actions are required. Best practices from around the world, as well as Canada’s own banking sector, provide examples. Government has an important role to play in advancing the establishment of targets for women’s representation on boards, providing guidance around board renewal mechanisms, tracking progress on the number of women on boards and further engaging with the business community to drive understanding of the need for change. Additionally, it needs to lead by modeling the behaviour it expects to see.
Organizations also have a role to play by taking action to champion women, leading systemic and rapid change, and working with government to achieve shared objectives.
The recommendations listed below can help accelerate progress for women on boards. They are aimed at three important stakeholders: organizations, leaders within organizations and governments.
- Companies and Business Leaders: Set goals and champion women
- Set the following specific targets by the end of 2017, and achieve them within three to five years:
- 30 per cent women board directors for all publicly-traded (non-venture) companies that currently have at least one woman director.
- One woman board director for all such companies that currently have zero women board directors.
- Use at least one mechanism—such as director term and/or age limits—to facilitate board renewal.
- Establish a written policy describing how the company specifically plans to increase representation of women on its board.
- Review board recruitment policies.
- Require that lists of potential board candidates consist of at least 50 per cent women with the skills and profile sought, and include women from diverse communities.
- Require that women—including women from diverse communities—comprise at least 50 per cent of the interview pool for every open board position.
- Implement board-effectiveness assessments, including gap analysis, using skills matrices.
- Leverage broad networks — not just the usual suspects — to connect supply with demand.
- Champion senior executive women for board service by:
- Reassessing and removing restrictions on external board service.
- Implementing programs to match talent with board vacancies, for both executive and non-executive director seats.
- Address gender equity at all levels of the organization by:
- Reviewing, on a continual basis, recruitment, promotion, and talent development systems to ensure they are unbiased.
- Investing in inclusive leadership training.
- Monitoring and tracking promotion rates, aiming for proportional promotion and retention at each level.
- Evaluating and addressing pay equity by conducting pay equity studies to determine if there are wage gaps and, if so, providing funds to rectify them. Also, implementing “no negotiations” policies and paying for work, not potential; and adopting pay transparency policies.
- Governments: define goals, track progress, and be role models for firms
- Drive greater awareness among broader stakeholder groups and the general public by implementing an action-oriented public awareness campaign. Government has an important role to play in promoting understanding and action on these issues.
- Reinforce and encourage the setting of specific targets, board renewal mechanisms, and written policies as a strong call to action for companies.
- Ensure progress continues to be tracked and published, as the Ontario Securities Commission (OSC) has done, on an annual basis to maintain transparency of corporate governance practices relating to the representation of women.
- If sufficient progress is not made, particularly toward a 30 per cent target, consider more stringent legislative or regulatory approaches.
- Model exemplary behaviour by reviewing appointments to their own agencies, boards, commissions and Crown corporations, and setting a minimum goal of at least 40 per cent women in these bodies by the end of 2019.
Tanya van Biesen is executive director of Catalyst Canada, the leading global nonprofit working to accelerate progress for women through workplace inclusion. In this capacity, Ms. van Biesen is responsible for leading the growth of Catalyst’s operations in Canada, shaping strategies to advance Catalyst’s mission with supporters, corporate partners, professional organizations, CEOs, senior leaders, and stakeholders. She spoke at Universities Canada’s Converge 2017.
About Universities Canada
Universities Canada is the voice of Canada’s universities at home and abroad, advancing higher education, research and innovation for the benefit of all Canadians.
Canada must get its house in order, or risk losing the global fight for talent
New Canadian scholarship program addresses inequality in developing countries
Johnston: Let's boost international education for Canadian students
International education leaders convene, discuss Canada as a global study destination